*HTML is ON *UBB Code is ON Smilies Legend
Smilies Legend
If you have previously registered, but forgotten your password, click here.
T O P I C R E V I E WDCCollectorI am new to the world of beta cloth, but I saw several beta cloth patches being sold on eBay.Is there anything I should keep in mind when shopping around for beta cloth patches? I saw from a previous thread that there was commemorative set, including the Apollo XI mission patch, issued by the manufacturer of the cloth. How does one ensure he gets the "right kind" or "true" beta cloth?spaced outOne thing to watch out for is patches with printing errors, particularly where one or more of the colors is offset from the rest. These errors are quite common and such patches were probably factory rejects.The Apollo 11 you mention on eBay is a good (or bad) example of this, especially noticeable around the Eagle's head and wings.Go4Launch quote:Originally posted by DCCollector:How does one ensure he gets the "right kind" or "true" beta cloth? The only significant Apollo-era "non-official" beta cloth emblems I am aware of are the two commemorative Apollo 11 ones issued by Owens-Corning. The crew insignia one is easily-identifiable because it is missing "Apollo 11" at the top; the other one is a "Man on the Moon" commemorative that bears no real relationship to an official crew design. So other than those two, I'd says almost 100% of anything else you run across will be "authentic." And yes, as spaced out says, the color registration can be off a bit -- which is why, in many cases, they are now available since they were rejects. Danno quote:Originally posted by Go4Launch: So other than those two, I'd says almost 100% of anything else you run across will be "authentic." I have wondered for awhile what would keep someone from buying a roll of betacloth and silkscreening their own patches? It seems like they would make quite a bit of money.By the way, it may not be very ethical (especially if you are selling them as vintage) but it would certainly be technically simple.JFS61I've worried about this as well. I know of at least one roll of Apollo-era beta cloth that was auctioned off recently, and with the advances in computer graphics, etc., I wonder how hard it would really be for someone who was determined enough to cut new screens, match ink colors, and then start cranking these things out. There have been rumors about this happening in the past, but I never knew if they were anything more than just that. Maybe someone out there who is a more knowledgeable expert on beta cloth, and has been collecting longer than I have could shed some light on this for us.DCCollectorThanks for the helpful info. Is there some place that sells authentic, quality beta cloth patches, or are these items you have to be on the lookout for?Go4LaunchI've also heard rumors of remakes, but have never seen any evidence. I think it may be a "space urban legend." I'm also not so sure it would be all that cost-effective. Apollo Beta panels seem to show up fairly regularly and can be had on eBay for (sometimes) as low as $40-$50 each. I also THINK they'd be pretty easy to spot, given the presumed difficulty of matching the colors and shades exactly (also figuring in the cost of the blank Beta cloth). YankeeTraderBob seems to have a pretty good supply and sells on eBay, but I'm not aware of a source that you can simply order from.Like other collectibles, these seemed extremely scare before the advent of the Internet. I've been amazed how many "extras" were made...DannoYou would not need to get Apollo era beta cloth as there is still quite a bit of beta cloth manufactured today (and used in many space applications besides STS, ISS, and spacesuits) and it is not very expensive relatively speaking. It would also not be a big deal to color match as silk screening has been around for a long time.I would be more concerned about the guys who seem to have an endless supply. How many of these beta cloth patches were made in the late 60s and early 70s??It would be well worth it if you could get $40 - $100 or more for rare ones as it may cost about $3 each in small quantities to make.To me this is also similar to kapton sales. Kapton is still widely used in space applications and is not very expensive yet people are always buying very small pieces for hundreds of dollars with dubious provinance. While there are many legitimate items out there I would almost never trust the guys who copy an original Williams COA and tell you they cut up the original.spacemanI've also wondered just how many beta cloth emblems are out there. What was the need to print lots for each mission?Is there a resource available detailing missions, number produced, number flown in space, to the moon, to the surface, etc.?Robert PearlmanTo my knowledge, no such compiled or public list exists. That said, a few astronauts have shared the quantity they carried or were given after their mission.For example, according to a COA he provided for the Astronaut Scholarship Foundation's 2003 auction, Jim Lovell had 450 beta cloth patches inside his PPK on Apollo 13. Other astronauts have revealed packages of 250 beta cloth patches each (unflown) that they were provided post mission for use as souvenirs.Thus it wasn't like they produced just enough patches to attach to their suits and that was it. It would not surprise me if some missions carried as many as 1000 beta cloth patches, and that an equal number or greater were left on Earth. JfoustI just bought the "From the Earth to the Moon" DVD set and began watching it for the first time this weekend.After seeing about five hours of it, and dipping my toe into patch collecting, I started to wonder about how the some of the emblems on the pressure suit costumes were handled. The close-ups in the credits look pretty good to me. I admit I've not gotten down to the "freeze-frame" state yet, cause I just want to take the whole thing in. BUT after reading some of the things in this thread particularly, I wonder if anyone has touched on where the emblems for the miniseries were obtained, and what safeguards were in place to prevent duping of the beta cloth emblems.Tried a search, but didn't come up with much.Robert PearlmanThe spacesuits filmed for "From the Earth to the Moon" were provided by Global Effects. As far as I know, the replica patches remain in their collection of props.MikeSpaceWere all beta cloth mission patches made before missions, or were some made after, meaning, are there 'levels' of rarity for these. I own and have seen beta cloth Apollo 11 patches that don't have the words 'Apollo 11' above the eagle. Thought I read somewhere these were either a prototype, or sold after missions as a collectible.Can the process be repeated today, either manufacture of beta, or of taking a blank beta and applying a mission patch to it?I've found these a real interesting collectible and am also trying to obtain a patch from each mission. I've seen the NASA Meatball and American flag patches, I was also wondering what other non-mission beta patches might exist.Editor's note: Threads merged.spaced outI cover some of your questions on the Beta Cloth Patches page of my Crew Patches website.MikeSpaceHuge help thanks!Sounds like getting wrinkles out these is an exercise in futility. spaced outMaybe there is a way of getting out creases - if someone knows the method do please let us know.arjunaMike, can't remember if Chris has info on this on his site, but there are two non-flown project beta patches that I know of: 2TV-1, and SMEAT.
Is there anything I should keep in mind when shopping around for beta cloth patches? I saw from a previous thread that there was commemorative set, including the Apollo XI mission patch, issued by the manufacturer of the cloth. How does one ensure he gets the "right kind" or "true" beta cloth?
The Apollo 11 you mention on eBay is a good (or bad) example of this, especially noticeable around the Eagle's head and wings.
quote:Originally posted by DCCollector:How does one ensure he gets the "right kind" or "true" beta cloth?
And yes, as spaced out says, the color registration can be off a bit -- which is why, in many cases, they are now available since they were rejects.
quote:Originally posted by Go4Launch: So other than those two, I'd says almost 100% of anything else you run across will be "authentic."
By the way, it may not be very ethical (especially if you are selling them as vintage) but it would certainly be technically simple.
There have been rumors about this happening in the past, but I never knew if they were anything more than just that. Maybe someone out there who is a more knowledgeable expert on beta cloth, and has been collecting longer than I have could shed some light on this for us.
YankeeTraderBob seems to have a pretty good supply and sells on eBay, but I'm not aware of a source that you can simply order from.
Like other collectibles, these seemed extremely scare before the advent of the Internet. I've been amazed how many "extras" were made...
I would be more concerned about the guys who seem to have an endless supply. How many of these beta cloth patches were made in the late 60s and early 70s??
It would be well worth it if you could get $40 - $100 or more for rare ones as it may cost about $3 each in small quantities to make.
To me this is also similar to kapton sales. Kapton is still widely used in space applications and is not very expensive yet people are always buying very small pieces for hundreds of dollars with dubious provinance. While there are many legitimate items out there I would almost never trust the guys who copy an original Williams COA and tell you they cut up the original.
Is there a resource available detailing missions, number produced, number flown in space, to the moon, to the surface, etc.?
For example, according to a COA he provided for the Astronaut Scholarship Foundation's 2003 auction, Jim Lovell had 450 beta cloth patches inside his PPK on Apollo 13.
Other astronauts have revealed packages of 250 beta cloth patches each (unflown) that they were provided post mission for use as souvenirs.
Thus it wasn't like they produced just enough patches to attach to their suits and that was it. It would not surprise me if some missions carried as many as 1000 beta cloth patches, and that an equal number or greater were left on Earth.
After seeing about five hours of it, and dipping my toe into patch collecting, I started to wonder about how the some of the emblems on the pressure suit costumes were handled. The close-ups in the credits look pretty good to me. I admit I've not gotten down to the "freeze-frame" state yet, cause I just want to take the whole thing in. BUT after reading some of the things in this thread particularly, I wonder if anyone has touched on where the emblems for the miniseries were obtained, and what safeguards were in place to prevent duping of the beta cloth emblems.
Tried a search, but didn't come up with much.
I own and have seen beta cloth Apollo 11 patches that don't have the words 'Apollo 11' above the eagle. Thought I read somewhere these were either a prototype, or sold after missions as a collectible.
Can the process be repeated today, either manufacture of beta, or of taking a blank beta and applying a mission patch to it?
I've found these a real interesting collectible and am also trying to obtain a patch from each mission.
I've seen the NASA Meatball and American flag patches, I was also wondering what other non-mission beta patches might exist.
Editor's note: Threads merged.
Sounds like getting wrinkles out these is an exercise in futility.
Contact Us | The Source for Space History & Artifacts
Copyright 1999-2024 collectSPACE. All rights reserved.